Previously, hiring teams favored candidates who “fit” the current workplace culture. Yet, the more they hire the same personality, background, and identity, the more that approach maintains homogeneity. It created industries that were male-dominated, racially-biased, or extremely niche. Shifting to a “culture add” mentality—where the focus is on what new hires bring to the culture—offers a more inclusive and forward-thinking approach. Let’s delve into the issues with prioritizing culture fit, and five strategies HR leaders can use to implement culture add.
What is Culture Fit and Culture Add?
Culture Fit refers to the idea of hiring candidates who align with the existing values, behaviors, and practices of an organization. The premise is that such individuals will seamlessly integrate into the team, contributing to a harmonious and cohesive work environment.
Culture Add, on the other hand, emphasizes the value that diverse perspectives and backgrounds bring to a company. This approach searches for candidates who still align with the company’s core values but also introduce new ideas, experiences, and viewpoints that can drive innovation and growth.
The Issues with Culture Fit
Lack of Diversity
The most obvious issue with culture fit is how it often results in a lack of diversity. The homogeneity can stifle creativity and limit the range of perspectives within the company. It also excludes qualified candidates who do not exactly demonstrate the existing culture.
Groupthink
Companies that thrive in competitive markets stand out by offering unique products or services. When everyone thinks alike, innovation suffers. Groupthink is when there is an emphasis on conforming to the consensus, and it can lead to poor decision-making.
Unconscious Bias
Cultural fit can perpetuate unconscious biases, where hiring decisions are influenced by similarities rather than professional qualifications or potential contributions.
Stagnation
A workforce that lacks diversity can become stagnant, resistant to change, and ill-equipped to navigate a dynamic future.
Exclusionary Practices
Emphasizing cultural fit can alienate individuals who might bring valuable new perspectives but don’t fit the existing mold, leading to exclusionary practices that hinder the advancement and retention of talented individuals.
5 Strategies to Implement Culture Add
1. Redefine Hiring Criteria
Instead of focusing on how candidates fit into the existing culture, HR leaders should define criteria based on the unique value each candidate can add. This involves broadening job descriptions to emphasize the importance of diverse experiences and perspectives.
For instance, rather than stating that the ideal candidate should “fit into our fun and fast-paced environment,” describe the qualities that would enhance the team, such as “bring fresh ideas to enhance our collaborative culture.”
2. Incorporate Diverse Interview Panels
To minimize bias and ensure a variety of perspectives are considered, assemble diverse interview panels. This approach ensures that multiple viewpoints are considered, reducing the risk of unconscious bias. Include team members from different departments, levels of seniority, and backgrounds in the interview process to provide a comprehensive evaluation of each candidate.
If the culture is too homogeneous to develop a diverse interview panel, consider using blind hiring methods. It separates the candidate’s identity from their qualifications, allowing recruiters to minimize unconscious bias in their decision-making process. Blind hiring strategies are most effective in the initial screening stage of recruiting and are not a permanent solution to diminishing culture fit mentality.
3. Focus on Core Values and Potential
While maintaining alignment with the company’s core values is essential, HR leaders should also assess candidates for their potential to contribute in new and meaningful ways. Cultural add mentality is about filling in the gaps in the current workforce.
Look for qualities such as adaptability, creativity, and problem-solving skills. Ask candidates anecdotal questions to reveal more of their qualities such as, “Can you describe a time when you introduced a new idea or approach in a previous role and the impact it had?”
4. Promote Creativity
Creating an environment where all employees feel valued and included is crucial for a culture add approach. Form spaces where team members can freely create together without fear of negative consequences. Over time, the organization will gain a reputation as a welcoming place for everyone.
5. Evaluate and Iterate
Continuously assess the effectiveness of the culture add approach and make necessary adjustments. It is not easy to change a team’s mindset around recruiting. Consider ways to gather feedback, monitor diversity metrics, and stay informed about best practices to ensure your hiring practices embrace adding to the workplace culture.
Shifting from a culture fit to a culture add approach is not only about hiring practices; it’s about fundamentally transforming an organization’s views. Embracing culture add not only enhances diversity but also drives creativity, growth, and long-term success. It’s time to move beyond fitting in and start creating the future.
Discover Proven Diversity Recruiting Strategies with TalentAlly
TalentAlly, a rebrand of the Professional Diversity Network (PDN), connects job seekers nationally to companies that truly value DEI. Contact us today to find out how we can help with your unique recruitment needs.
